PLEASE NOTE:

PLEASE NOTE: The posts here are strictly meant as supplement notes for participants of the study group, and not for a non-participant.
Non participants of the study group may not clearly understand the subjective aspects of the post, and could be confused. Hence, it is recommend that non-participants do not refer to this BLOG, and instead attend the study group first.
Study group meets on Sunday's at 12.45 pm @ Chinmaya Vrindavan, 95, Cranbury Neck Road, Cranbury, NJ

Saturday, April 27, 2024

Class Summary for April 21, 2024 - Bhagavad Gita Chapter-8 ver 23- 26

Summarized by Prasanna Kumar: 


We started with prayanam and meditation and then Recap  

We talked about the two paths before us at the time of leaving earth. Krishna Gati the path of darkness and Suklah Gati the path of light.

Also mentioned is the significance of time of the day or time of the year of one’s departure from this earth.

Uttarayana is referred to as the day of new good healthy wealthy beginning. In the Mahabharata, this day marks the death of Bhishma. Bhishma had the ability to choose the time of his death and although mortally wounded in war during Dakshinayana , he chose to delay his death until uttarayan.According to the Bhagavad Gita, a Hindu scripture, those who die when the Sun is on its e northward course (from south to north) attain nirvana.This explains the choice made by Bhishma to wait until Uttarayana to die. But was that the real reason for Bhishma’s wait ?. 

From the point of Srimad Bhagavatam he waited for so long because Bhishma knew that Shree Krishna wanted him to perform a service. He wanted Bhishma to see the ultimate triumph of those whom he loved, who were virtuous, who followed the path of Dharma — The Pandavas. At another deeper level, Shree Krishna wanted to glorify his devotee Bhishma. Even though some people may think that Bhishma was short shortsighted in siding with the Kauravas and that it did muddle his intellect but that was not the case. The war had not affected his clarity of thought, his intelligence and his virtuosity. So when Yudhishthira became disconsolate grieving terribly for having being the cause of bloodshed in the Kurukshetra war, no body was able to convince him. Not even Lord Krishna but it was only Bhishma who was able to do it. He gave deeper and meaningful instructions to Yudhishthira on statesmanship and duties of a King. He also gave Vishnu Sahasranama , thousand names of Lord Vishnu, during this time to him. Shree Krishna, in this way, wanted the world to know that Bhishma’s wisdom was greater than everyone else. Then Krishna offered him the perfect departure by being at his side at that time . This is the ultimate success of a devotee. By beholding the Lord by his side in front of him externally, by meditating the Lord inside his heart internally, he left this world with certainty that he will unite with the Supreme . Shree Krishna wanted him to wait so that the depth of his wisdom can be known, his clarity of consciousness despite pain of 100s of arrows can be known, his virtuosity can be known. In this way, Supreme Lord Shree Krishna orchestrated the perfect departure for Bhishma!

According to the Hindu tradition the six month period of Uttarayana is equivalent to a single day of the Gods, while the six month period of Dakshinayana is equal to a single night of the Gods. Thus a year of twelve months is single day of the Gods. This refers to the six months of single day at the North pole and concurrent six months of night at the south pole.

 Bhagavad Gita: Chapter 8, Verse 23-26

Commentary ( reference holy bhaghavad-gita.org)

In these verses, Shree Krishna continues to answer the question Arjun had asked in verse 8.2, “How can one be united with God at the time of death?”

Shree Krishna explains that there are two paths—the path of light ( Shuklah Gati) or the path of darkness (Krishna Gati). Where light; is symbolic to knowledge and darkness; is for ignorance.

The bright daylight, the moonlit fortnight of śhuklaḥ or the bright ascending moon, and the uttaraayan, the northern course of the sun, are all considered the time of light. The God-conscious souls; who detach from worldly attachments and depart by the path of light (knowledge and discrimination) attain God. They are liberated from the wheel of samsara, the cycle of life and death, and reach the divine Abode of God.

The ignorant souls who are attached to the world remain entangled in the bodily concept of life. They forget their relationship with God. Such souls depart by the path of darkness. Hence, continue to rotate in the cycle of life and death. However, those who may have undertaken some Vedic rituals, as its fruit, go to the celestial abodes. But this position is also part of the material world, thus temporary. When their merits are exhausted, they have to return to earth. Ultimately all humans born on earth, upon death, have to pass along either of the two paths, the path of light or the path of darkness. It is their karmas that decide which path they would take eventually.

Verse 27

Those relentless souls who strive for Yog or union with God are true yogis. They recognize themselves to be tiny fragments of God and His eternal beatitude. They also realize the temporary nature of the material world and the futility of a materialistic life. Therefore, instead of running behind sensual pleasures, they endeavour to enhance their love for God. Such souls are on the path of light.

On the other hand are the ignorant souls, who are under the influence of maya, the material energy. They recognize themselves as only the body and the material world around them as the source of their pleasure. They continue to live through the miseries of material existence, being disdainful toward God or His eternal opulence. Thus, such souls are on the path of darkness.

In this verse, Shree Krishna urges Arjun to recognize the difference between these two paths and choose the path of light, thus become a yogi. It is not that many of us do not take the path of light, but after some time are back on the path of darkness. 

For instance, someone wishes to go east and walks one mile toward the rising sun in the morning. He rests in the afternoon for a while. Then he starts walking again toward the sun, which is now in the west. He walks for two miles only to find in the evening that he is one mile farther in the west from where he had started.  Similarly, treading on the path of light only for some time will not work; it needs to be a constant process, else one will slip back into darkness again. Therefore, in this verse, Shree Krishna adds the phrase, “at all times.” It is for us to recognize the importance of being a yogi at all times. And avoid the danger of sliding back into the path of darkness.

In Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 8, Verse 28,( from copilot) 

 Lord Krishna imparts profound wisdom. Let’s explore the commentary on this verse:

Sanskrit Verse (8.28):

वेदेषु यज्ञेषु तप:सु चैव दानेषु यत्पुण्यफलं प्रदिष्टम् | अत्येति तत्सर्वमिदं विदित्वा योगी परं स्थानमुपैति चाद्यम् || 28 ||

Translation:

“The yogis, who know this secret, gain merit far beyond the fruits of Vedic rituals, the study of the Vedas, performance of sacrifices, austerities, and charities. Such yogis reach the Supreme Abode.”


Commentary:

In this verse, Lord Krishna reveals that those yogis who follow the path of light reap rewards beyond what other processes can bestow. Even though one may undertake Vedic sacrifices, perform austerities, engage in charity, or accumulate knowledge of the self, without devotion to God, it is not the path of light. The Ramayan states:

“You may engage in good conduct, righteousness, austerities, sacrifices, ashtanga yoga, chanting of mantras, and charity. But without devotion to God, the mind’s disease of material consciousness will not cease.”

All these good deeds can only yield temporary material rewards. However, devotion to God leads to liberation from the bondage of the material world. Therefore, the yogis who have realized this truth detach their minds from the material world and attach them to God alone. By treading this path of light, they eventually attain eternal happiness.

This verse emphasizes the importance of devotion and spiritual realization in transcending worldly limitations and reaching the Supreme Abode. 

🙏Om Shanthi! 


Saturday, April 20, 2024

Class Summary forApril 14, 2024 - Bhagavad Gita Chapter-8 ver 23- 26

 Summarized by Bala Dhandapani:

The class discussed points from the April 7th session

Summary/recap:

Goal to reach Mukti is also a bondage.

With Krama Mukti path, one reaches Brahmaloga.  Brahma teaches how to give away the desire to get Mukti, then one would attain Brahman.

Class watched Gurudev’s videos 23, 24, 25 and 26

Summary of the videos

-          Sun represents Spirit and Moon represents Matter

-          When sun comes up everything is dynamic and active

-          Moon is reverse – one would sit down and watch

-          Gurudev points out that no one says Honey Sun !! only Honey Moon !!.

-          Moon represents matter and sun represents energy and dynamism

-          Moon path and sun path is a way of saying.  Moon path is still attached to the matter and enjoyment.

-          For a Karmi, above are the 2 paths

-          Gurudev further expounds on the 2 paths.  The path of no return (Light/Sun) and the path of return (darkness/Moon)

-          Those who are NOT attached to matter and only to spiritual takes the Sun/Light/Bright path. 

-          Those who are attached to matter takes the Moon/dark- road of smoke path and reaches heaven and comes back.

-          The sun and moon paths are the 2 choices always available. 

-          Krama mukti is liberation in stages


Subjective Analysis:  Practice Karma Yoga, Bhakti Yoga and Gyana Yoga through Shravanam, Mananam and Nidityasanam. 

Saturday, April 13, 2024

Class Summary forApril 7, 2024 - Bhagavad Gita Chapter-8 ver 23- 26

Summarized by Anand Santhanam:

Summary

Pursuit of happiness. 

- As we look inward, we will realize the ultimate truth. 

- The cycle of manifest and unmanifest continues

- The supreme is the one that is always the seer. When something is moving there is always a constant that is observing the change. Because of this constant observer, we know that there is a change. 

- There is difference between love and devotion. 

- Differences in the Shruti, Yukthi and Anubhavam. 


Sloka 23-26

These are very controversial slokas

There are two routes taken by the Atma

- Moon path allows the Athma to enjoy the fruits of your action, and then come back for “re-birth. This is applicable for most humans who indulge in materialistic or selfish actions.

- Sun path attains moksha

Those who do their un-selfish karmas and also meditate on the supreme Brahman, attain moksha. They will initially go to Brahma loka, where lord Brahma will provide knowledge. They they will eventually merge with the Brahman at the time of Pralaya. 

Few exceptional cases who are totally surrendered to the Brahman, and perform actions only for the welfare of this creation reach Brahman directly. 


Themes

- path of ignorance has Vaasanas. Involves hell/heaven and rebirths 

- Path of knowledge leads to Brahman/Moksha either through Brahma loka (Krama Mukthi) or Directly (Kaivalya mukti). 

Saturday, April 6, 2024

Class Summary for March 24 2024 - Bhagavad Gita Chapter-8 ver 20- 22

Summarized by Bala Dhandapani:

Chapter 8, The Imperishable Truth

After pranayama and meditation, salient points from previous class were summarized. 

Pursuit is an action.  Happiness is already in us.  How to realize is to remove the veil.


Theme from previous class

Beyond the manifest state and unmanifest state is Brahman

All of us are in pursuit of happiness  à Brahman is the absolute happiness

There is no return once we realize. 

How to get there à one need to raise above the common materialistic world through undistracted focus and Unwavering devotion

 

Class watched Gurudev’s videos

Salient points from the videos

Verse 20

Vasanas are exhausted in the manifest phase.  There is a constant cycle of unmanifest -manifest-unmanifest which is also the cycle of creation and dissolution.  There is a larger unmanifestation that is Brahman.  He (Brahman) is present in everyone and everything.  Mind is changing constantly and so is Intellect.  Everything is changing constantly, but there is a changeless in the midst if all these changes is Brahman.

Substitute a lower vasanas with a higher vasanas.  Hold on to something that is not changing. 

Intellectually no one will accept on the changeless.  How do you know that everything is changing?

Who is experiencing these changes, the experiencer – so the experiencer has to be changeless to recognize. 

Example:  OPT OP1T1 OP2TPerceiver and Thinker can be changing, the changeless is the observer. 

To see the change one need to be the changeless observer. 


Verse 21

Akshara means Immutable, this is the Supreme goal to be reached.  The changeless is the Supreme State.  Once reached the state cannot come back.  The Infinite state is beyond time and is permanent and immutable. That is the Supreme State not the Krishna who is Devaki Putra. 

Krishna is giving instruction on how to contemplate in the next verse.  Pure consciousness is the true nature. 

 

Verse 22

To the Supreme Purusha one need to be total loyal and with complete devotion with no otherness. 

Ananya bhakti  is no other thought – Total Bhakti. 

What is Devotion ? Devotion is the love for the Supreme. 


Difference between Love and Devotion.

When someone is in love with another (like a teenager) we say Fallen in Love , “fallen” is going down.  Where as Rising in Love is Devotion. 

Lower – Love,  Higher – Devotion.  Emotion is love, love lifted to a higher alter is devotion. 

To understand devotion, analyze love.  Love is the identification with the beloved, more of me in my beloved.  Bhakti is devotion to the Lord.  How much one totally surrender to him and ready to suffer for him is devotion.

Devotion is Total identification to the lord, not by mere saying. 

Everything is existing in space.  Consider the relationship between waves and ocean.  We all are waves of the consciousness.  Narayana is one essence. 


Subjective Analysis

Practice:

Shruthi à dedicated focus in learning,

Yukthi à Understanding what you have learnt, doing the analysis- even taking experiences from others and understanding the same.

Anubhavam à your own experience, reiterating and validating the experience.

From Shravanam, Mananam and Nidityasanam learn with intensity from an intellect perspective     

...

    Monday, March 4, 2024

    Class Summary for March 3, 2024 - Bhagavad Gita Chapter-8 ver 20- 22

     Summarized by Rajesh:

    • We started with a recap of the last class
    • Time dilation works every night while we dream.  On average, dreams last for 90 seconds - we live lifetimes in a dream.
    • Sum of ignorances is Maya (?)

    Verse 20, 21 & 22

    Verse translation

    • Verse 20:  Transcendental to this manifest and unmanifest creation, there is yet another unmanifest eternal dimension.  That realm does not cease even when all others do.
    • Verse 21:  That manifest dimension is the supreme goal, and upon reaching it, one never returns to this mortal world.  That is My Supreme Abode.
    • Verse 22:  The Supreme Divine Being is greater than all that exists.  Although He is all-pervading and all living beings are situated in Him, yet He can be known only through devotion.


    Discussion about verses

    • We can’t take for granted that Devotion is the only path from this last line - Karma Yoga & Jnana Yoga are also necessary.  Famous example is of a disciple to Swamiji - “I’ve gone through the Bhagvad Gita 21 times but nothing has changed.”  Swamiji asked the disciple “how many times has the Bhagvad Gita gone through you?”  It is about dropping the ego and having true faith.
    • We can’t be just professional Jnanis or professional Karma Yogis. We need all three - Jnana, Karma & Bhakti.  In my own interpretation, we need theory & practice along with belief.
    • Karma Yoga, especially Nishkama Karma or the self-less or desire less action, cleans our minds.  We have to focus this free space in our mind with Bhakti Yoga, otherwise the mind is filled with other thoughts.  Ultimately, we get Jnana.


    Theme

    • Manifest state is represented by Waking and Dream states
    • Unmanifest state is represented by Deep sleep state
    • Beyond both Manifest and Unmanifest states is Brahman
    • All of us are in pursuit of happiness -> Brahman is ultimate happiness (anandam) [There is no ‘pursuit of happiness’, at least not externally or materialistically.  We are ‘ananda’ but we have not realized it.]
    • There is NO coming back from this!
    • How do we get there?  Raising above this common materialistic wold through Undistracted focus and Unwavering devotion!